I have always specified (used) threaded schedule 40 fire protection systems. Why do I need to change?

In today's competitive market, using specially engineered pipe products provides you with an edge over the competition, without sacrificing the service life of the system. Roll grooved systems using Ultra Eddy or Eddy Flow have better flow rates than schedule 40 systems. These pipe products are lighter, easier to work with, and in most cases, they offer longer service life. Bull Moose Tube can roll groove these products right off the mill. Why take chances with the inconsistencies of threading on-site.

   
Why should I insist on FM approved and UL listed schedule 10 and schedule 40 pipe?
All pipe products are manufactured to meet one or more of ASTM standards. ASTM, however, does not have representatives out in the field to audit the pipe producers to ensure that all aspects of the applicable specification are being met. FM and UL, on the other hand, have representatives who go to the pipe mill to perform an audit. FM approval and UL listing are two of the ways to ensure that the pipe being used meets all requirements of the applicable ASTM specification.
   
Schedule 40 pipe, because of its heavy wall, is the best pipe. Correct?

Not necessarily. While it is true that schedule 40 has the heaviest wall of most pipe products used in the fire protection systems; the more important fact to consider is the wall thickness after the fabrication process. Most schedule 40 pipe is used in threaded systems. In certain sizes, the threading process can take the wall down to about 35% of the nominal wall. Since threads are tapered, the first exposed thread outside a fitting will be the weakest link in the system, causing failure due to rust.

Example:
1" schedule 40 pipe.
Nominal wall thickness: 0.133".
Wall thickness at first exposed thread: 0.044" (33% of nominal wall).

   
What benefit do I get by using a lightwall non-threadable pipe?
Non-threadable pipe has the same wall thickness throughout the system. No material is removed from the wall, as is the case with threaded systems. In most cases, a roll grooved system using Ultra will have a longer life span than a threaded schedule 40 system. In addition, roll grooved pipe offers better hydraulics than Schedule 40.

Example:
1" Bull Moose Tube Ultra pipe.
Nominal wall thickness: 0.065"
Minimum wall thickness: 0.057"(compared to 0.044" for schedule 40).

In this case, Bull Moose Tube Ultra will have a longer theoretical life span than schedule 40!

   
Besides a longer service life, what other benefits can I expect from a roll grooved system using a lightwall pipe?

Lightwall pipe, because of its larger inside diameter, offers better hydraulics. In most cases, one can use, say, 2 ½" Bull Moose Tube Eddy Flow instead of 3" schedule 40. Freight saving is another tangible benefit. A truck load of lightwall pipe will have more feet compared to a truck load of schedule 40 pipe.

Example:

Assuming T/L equals 44,000 lbs.

1" schedule 40: wt/ft 1.679 lbs.
Total feet per T/L: 44,000/1.679=26206

1" Bull Moose Tube Ultra: wt/ft 0.868
Total feet per T/L: 44,000/0.868=50691
Moreover, lightwall pipe, because of its lighter weight, is easier to work with.

In summary, a roll grooved system can have a longer life span, will offer better hydraulics, is easier to work with, and is cheaper to ship.

   
Where would I go if I have technical questions regarding Sprinkler pipe or its use?
Please call our technical support department at 888.227.5430, or contact us via email at techsupport@bullmoosetube.com.
 
 

2006 All rights reserved.